|
Marc Charron, Gatineau Quebec (December 8, 2007)
When my tire shop installed the Nokian Hakkapelitta SUV5 winter tire on my 2007 RAV4 V6 Sport SUV, they turned out to be studded instead of studless as I had requested. These tires have been top rated in test with Transport Canada and are considered as one of (if not the best) winter tire that can be purchased in Canada. My other winter tires include the Michelin X-Ice, another top-rated winter tire, a good basis of comparison.
A few quick calls from the tire shop to local police confirmed these studded were legal. After driving home, I did some research and was a bit surprised by what I found, and have identified a lot of myths and misconceptions regarding studded winter tires.
It appears that only Southern Ontario residents are restricted from the use of such tires since a ban was introduced in 1970 (yes, that was 37 years ago) on concerns that primitive heavy steel stud designs would cause excessive road damage.
Studies in Alaska and Scandinavian countries have shown the socio-economical (including environmental) cost-benefit favors studded tires over non-studded tires. The reports confirm increased safety (reduced injury rates), lower cost (vehicle damage claims) and reduced damage to roads & environment (from reduced use of road-salt).
Yet when you talk or read about studded tires, the amount of negative dis-information overwhelms the scientific information.
I?ve never seen/heard you opinions on studded tires. Given the popularity of your shows & the respect you have from your audience, you are in an ideal position to clear up a lot of these myths & misconceptions.
Would you be interested in commenting on this topic either on/off air? |
Great idea, we will do a show on winter tires.
I have Nokian WR's on my BMW X5 and love them. Studded tires are popular here in BC for mountain driving. |
|
|

|